Update on IRAs and Personal Bankruptcy Exemptions

When it comes to filing for bankruptcy, most Americans have been operating under the assumption that they'll be able to exempt retirement funds when they file for a Chapter 7 bankruptcy.  In other words, retirement savings accounts, such as those contained in individual retirement accounts (IRAs), typically can be exempted under federal law when someone files for consumer bankruptcy.  However, the recent U.S. Supreme Court ruling in Clark v. Rameker emphasizes that some exceptions exist when it comes to this rule.
Supreme Court Ruling: Inherited IRAs Aren't Retirement Funds
We previously discussed the potential implications of Clark v. Rameker when the case was still pending before the Supreme Court.  As a quick reminder, the case involves Heidi Heffron-Clark's inherited $450,000 traditional IRA.  Heidi inherited the IRA from her mother, Ruth, who named her daughter as the sole beneficiary.  When Heidi and her husband later decided to file for personal bankruptcy, they wanted the funds from the IRA to be exempt.
But on July 12, the Court ruled unanimously that inherited IRAs do not qualify as retirement funds such that they're exempt during a bankruptcy proceeding.
The Court didn't address whether traditional and Roth IRAs are exempt.  Rather, the holding relates strictly to IRAs that have been inherited.  In other words, the decision only applies to inherited retirement accounts.  
Justice Sonia Sotomayor wrote the unanimous decision, emphasizing that inherited IRA accounts do not qualify as retirement funds, and as such, they're not exempt during bankruptcy.  According to the decision, "the text and purpose of the Bankruptcy Code make clear that funds held in inherited IRAs are not 'retirement funds' within the meaning of the bankruptcy exemption."  
What was the Court's reasoning?  In short, inherited IRAs don't allow heirs to add money to the account.  So in other words, an heir can't fully use an IRA as if it were her own.  She can only take money from the account--she can't invest more money into the account for her own retirement.  Additionally, an heir can only make specific types of withdrawals and at certain times, which is also different from the way an original owner of an IRA can use the account.
Effects on Future Personal Bankruptcy Proceedings
According to an article in Insurance News Net, the decision "has turned the estate planning committee on its head."  Indeed, one retirement and financial planning specialist asserted that the Court's decision is "sending seismic shock waves through the estate planning community."  What's the big deal?
One financial analyst suggested that the decision will "make it easier for creditors and bankruptcy attorneys to lay claim on inherited retirement assets."  According to Eleanor Blayney, a consumer advocate with the Board of Certified Financial Planners, the Court's decision "points to a significant chunk of American wealth that is now, quite clearly, no longer as 'bulletproof' from creditors as most thought."
As of last years, IRAs across the country contained about $6.5 trillion in total, and Blayney estimates that about $54 billion of those assets may no longer be protected.  
Dealing with exemptions during consumer bankruptcy can be complicated, but an experienced Oak Park bankruptcy lawyer can help with your case.  Contact the Emerson Law Firm today to learn more about how we can help consumers with debts and personal bankruptcy.
See Related Blog Posts:


Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

New Information on Debts That Bankruptcy Cannot Discharge

If you are thinking about filing for bankruptcy in the Oak Park area, it is important to know that certain kinds of debts cannot be discharged in a bankruptcy case. Under U.S. bankruptcy law, these are known as non-dischargeable debts, or exceptions to discharge. There are certain types of debts that have long been identified clearly as non-dischargeable debts, while there are misconceptions about other types of debts that may or may not be dischargeable. As an article in CNBC discusses, the U.S. Supreme Court recently issued a ruling in the case of Bartenwerfer v. Buckley , which clarifies that debts incurred due to another party’s fraud cannot be discharged in an individual’s bankruptcy case. Our Oak Park bankruptcy attorneys can explain the Court’s recent ruling and provide you with additional information on dischargeable and non-dischargeable debts. Supreme Court Says Debt Incurred Due to Another’s Fraud is Non-Dischargeable The recent Bartenwerfer case involved a debtor attempti
Read more

Learning About Different Types of Wills

Whether you are young or old, single or married, wealthy or with limited financial means, healthy or dealing with a medical condition, it is important to make a will. Many people have incorrectly heard that wills are only necessary for particular people, such as those with a substantial amount of assets or for older adults in poor health. Yet wills are critical for adults of all ages, and an experienced Oak Park estate planning lawyer can help you to make one. Before you begin working with a lawyer on a will, you might start conducting your own research into wills in Illinois and the requirements for a valid will. In so doing, you are likely to come across information about many different types of wills, and you are probably going to wonder whether you will need more than one kind of will. In short, there are different terms that can be used to describe the form or function of a will, as well as some distinct types of wills. Our Oak Park estate planning attorneys can explain in more
Read more

Younger Parents Need an Estate Plan

It is critical for younger parents to have an estate plan, even if they know they are healthy and do not anticipate that anything will happen in the near future. Much too often, younger parents assume that they can wait until they are older to consider estate planning or until there is a health-related reason to begin the estate planning process. Yet estate planning is critically important for parents who have minor children. While estate planning is important for adults of all ages, it can allow parents to make important decisions about who will care for their children in the event that they become unable to do so themselves. Our Oak Park estate planning lawyers can explain in more detail. Naming a Guardian for Your Minor Children in Your Will Most importantly for younger parents, making a will allows you to name a guardian who can care for your child in the event of your unexpected death. Nobody anticipates a deadly accident or a sudden situation in which there is a need for another
Read more